Arctic Ice Regime Shipping System
- Table of Contents
- List of Abbreviations
- A short guide to the steps in applying the Arctic Ice Regime Shipping System
- 1. Application
- 2. Ice Navigator
- 3. Ice Terminology
- 4. Entry
- 5. Ice Numeral
- 6. Ice Multipliers
- 7. Arctic Shipping Pollution Prevention Regulations
- 8. Using the System
- 9. Reporting Structure
- 10. Agencies
- 11. References & Bibliography
- Appendix A - Zones Map
- Appendix B - Extract from the Arctic Shipping Pollution Prevention Regulations
- Appendix C - Shipping Safety Control Zones - Dates of Entry
- Appendix D - Template - Ice Regime Routing Message
The procedures and definitions provided in this publication apply to ships using the Arctic Ice Regime Shipping System [System] in a Shipping Safety Control Zone (Appendix A) as required by the Arctic Shipping Pollution Prevention Regulations (Appendix B). This means navigation outside the entry dates (Appendix C) set out in the regulations.
The procedures are intended to assist the Master in deciding whether to enter an ice regime or not. The Regulations require that the decision to enter an ice regime be based on the Master’s assessment that the ship is capable to navigate safely through the ice regime.
The System can be used only by those ships which meet the design and construction requirements of either Canadian Arctic Category (CAC) 3 or 4 and all Type ships. There is no direct equivalency between the existing Arctic Classes and the new Canadian Arctic Categories. Owners of existing Arctic Class ships should apply to Marine Safety for the appropriate “Ice Multipliers” which are assessed on a case by case basis.
In accordance with section 6 of the Regulations, every ship using the Arctic Ice Regime Shipping System must have on board an Ice Navigator.
The ice navigator may be any person on board, including the Master, who meets the requirements of section 26 (3)(b) of the Regulations, which may be summarised as:
The ice navigator is required to have 50 days of experience as either the Master or a person in charge of the deck watch on ships operating in ice conditions that required the ship to
- be escorted by an icebreaker, or
- perform manoeuvres to prevent the ship from coming in contact with ice concentrations beyond the ship’s structural capability.
- Of these 50 days of experience, at least 30 days must have been obtained in the Arctic.
.1 The “ice terminology” used is generally in accordance with the World Meteorological Organization Publication: “WMO Sea-Ice Nomenclature”, reference WMO/OMM/BMO - No 259, as of March 1985. For information on ice and ice types, the mariner may also refer to “Manual of Standard Procedures for Observing and Reporting Ice Conditions (MANICE)”. For ease of reference, the main types of ice are as follows:
Decayed Ice: means
- multi-year ice,
- second-year ice,
- thick first-year ice, or
- medium first-year ice,
which has thaw holes formed, or is rotten ice;
Open Water: A large area of freely navigable water in which ice is present in concentrations of less than 1/10. No ice of land origin is present.
Young Ice: Ice in the transition range between nilas and first-year ice, 10-30 cm. in thickness. May be subdivided into grey ice and grey-white ice.
Grey Ice: Young ice 10-15 cm thick. Less elastic than nilas and breaks on swell. Usually rafts under pressure.
Grey-White Ice: Young ice 15-30 cm. thick. Under pressure it is more likely to ridge than to raft.
First-Year Ice: Sea ice of not more than one winter’s growth, developing from young ice 30 cm thick. It may be subdivided into thin first-year ice/white ice, medium first-year ice and thick first-year ice.
Thin First-year Ice/White Ice - First stage: First-year ice 30-50 cm. thick.
Thin First-year Ice/White Ice - Second stage: First-year ice 50-70 cm. thick.
Medium First-year Ice: First-year ice 70-120 cm. thick.
Thick First-year Ice: First-year ice over 120 cm. thick.
Old Ice: Sea ice which has survived at least one summer’s melt. Topographic features generally are smoother than first-year ice. It may be subdivided into second-year ice and multi-year ice.
Second-year Ice: Old ice which has survived only one summer’s melt. Thicker and less dense than first-year ice, it stands higher out of the water. In contrast to multi-year ice, summer melting produces a regular pattern of numerous small puddles. Bare patches and puddles are usually greenish-blue.
Multi-year Ice: Old ice which has survived at least two summer’s melt. Hummocks are smoother than on second-year ice and the ice is almost salt-free. Where bare, this ice is usually blue in colour. The melt pattern consists of large interconnecting, irregular puddles, and a well-developed drainage system.
.2 Open Water: For the purposes of this publication “Open Water” is an ice type. It includes Bergy Water, any concentration of New Ice (Frazil Ice / Grease Ice / Slush / Shuga) Nilas (Light or Dark / Ice Rind) and loose Brash Ice.
Bergy Water: An area of freely navigable water in which ice of land origin is present. Other ice types may be present, although the total concentration of all other ice is less than 1/10.
Brash Ice: Accumulation of floating ice made up of fragments not more than 2m across, the wreckage of other forms of ice.
New Ice: A general term for recently formed ice which includes frazil ice, grease ice, slush and shuga. These types of ice are composed of ice crystals which are only weakly frozen together (if at all) and have a definite form only while they are afloat.
Nilas Ice: A thin elastic crust of ice, easily bending on waves, and swell, and under pressure, growing in a pattern of interlocking “fingers” (finger rafting). Has a matte surface and is up to 10 cm. in thickness.
Outside the Zone Dates, ships using the Arctic Ice Regime Shipping System may only enter an ice regime when the Ice Numeral is equal to or greater than zero.
.1 The Ice Numeral is an assessment of an ice regime, in mathematical terms, which is used to determine whether the ship can enter the ice regime.
.2 The Ice Numeral, for an ice regime in any Shipping Safety Control Zone or part of a zone, is the sum of the products of the concentration, in tenths, of each ice type and the Ice Multiplier.
.1 Subject to subsection 6.2 below each ice type in columns III to XI of the Ice Multiplier Table, shall have the weighting in that column for the respective ship category in column 1.
.2 Where the total ice concentration in a regime is 6 tenths or greater and 3/10ths or more of an ice type is deformed by ridges, rubble or hummocking, the weighting for that ice type, taken from the Table, shall be decreased by 1, and for ‘decayed ice’ the weighting may be increased by 1.
|SHIP CATEGORY||ICE TYPE||OPEN WATER||GREY ICE||GREY WHITE ICE||THIN FIRST YEAR 1st STAGE||THIN FIRST YEAR 2nd STAGE||
|SECOND YEAR||MULTI YEAR|
|ICE TYPE SYMBOL1||OW||G||GW||FY||FY||MFY||TFY||SY||MY|
The Arctic Shipping Pollution Prevention Regulations control some aspects of navigation through what is commonly known as the Zone Date system.
In the Zone Date system, the Arctic waters are divided into sixteen Shipping Safety Control Zones, with a schedule of earliest and latest entry dates for each zone corresponding to specific categories of vessels (see Appendices A and C). Generally, Zone 1 has the most severe ice conditions and Zone 16 the least.
The Arctic Ice Regime Shipping System has been introduced to allow ships to navigate in the Arctic when the ice conditions allow. To use the system, it is important that the ice information on board the ship is current.
.1 Important Concepts
The Ice Regime System controls navigation on the basis of the actual ice conditions within a given area.
An ice regime is a relatively consistent distribution of any mix of ice types, including open water.
An ice regime is a region covered with generally consistent ice conditions i.e. the distribution of ice and concentrations does not change very much from point to point in this region. The boundaries between regimes mark major differences in the regional distribution of ice types and concentrations.
A regime may be only a few 100’s or 1000’s of square metres in area or may be many square kilometres in expanse. The determination of the size of a regime depends solely on the distribution of ice mix. A regime may consist of the broken track behind an icebreaker or other ship, which may give an Ice Numeral considerably different from the unbroken ice, which will be another regime.
An ice regime may contain some ice which is beyond the capabilities of a ship to pass through successfully, and much which is not. The decision to enter a given Ice Regime is based on the ability of the vessel to navigate through safely - avoiding the “dangerous” ice. The Ice Regime System provides mariners with a tool to help make this decision. The tool is a simple arithmetical calculation which uses Ice Multipliers to determine a Ice Numeral. If the value of the Ice Numeral is negative i.e. less than zero, then entry into the ice regime is avoided; a value of zero or greater indicates that entry may be considered.
.2 How the calculation works
Every ice type (including open water) has a numerical value which is dependent on the ice category of the vessel. This number is called an Ice Multiplier (IM). The value of the Ice Multiplier reflects the level of risk or operational constraint that the particular ice type poses to each category of vessel.
For any ice regime, a Ice Numeral (IN) is calculated by taking the sum of the products of the concentrations of the ice types present (in tenths) in the region and their ice multipliers. This is not as complicated as it may sound:
IN = (Ca × IMa) + (Cb × IMb) + ...
where: IN - Ice Numeral
Ca - concentration in tenths of ice type "a"
IMa - Ice Multiplier for ice type "a" (see Table)
The term on the right hand side of the equation (a, b, c, etc.) is repeated for as many ice types as may be present, including open water.
The Ice Numeral (IN) is therefore unique to the particular ice regime and the ship operating within its boundaries.
Following are two examples of Ice Numeral calculation.
SAMPLE ICE NUMERAL CALCULATIONS
Example - 1
The Ice Regime in Photo 1 has 1/10th of multi-year ice; and 9/10ths of first year ice.
CAC 4 (1× -3) + (9 × 2) i.e. (-3) + (18) = +15 (Ice Numeral)
(1, for 1/10th of multi-year ice multiplied by -3 which is the ice multiplier value from Table 1 for a CAC 4 ship in multi-year ice) + (9 which is for 9/10th’s of first-year ice multiplied by 2 the ice multiplier value from the Table 1 for CAC 4 ship in first year ice) gives 15, the Ice Numeral.
Type B (1× -4) + (9× -1) i.e. (-4) + (-9)= - 13 (Ice Numeral)
(1, for 1/10th of multi-year ice multiplied by -4, which is the ice-multiplier value from Table 1 for a Type B ship in multi-year ice) + (9 which is for 9/10ths of first-year ice multiplied by -1 the ice-multiplier value from the Table-1 for Type B ship in first year ice) gives -13, the Ice Numeral.
Example - 2
The Ice Regime in Photo 2 has : 5/10th second-year ice, 4/10ths first-year medium ice and 1/10th open water.
Type B (5 × -4) + (4 × -1) + (1 × 2) i.e. (-20) + (-4) + (2) = -22 (Ice Numeral)
Type A (5 × -3) + (4 × 1) + (1 × 2) i.e. (-15) + (4) + (2) = -9 (Ice Numeral)
To get an accurate IN, the Ice Multipliers should be adjusted for decayed ice and must be adjusted for ridged ice. The reason is that, a given ice type will be weaker when it is decayed and thicker when ridged.
In all cases, the due caution of the Mariner must be exercised, taking into account such factors as changes in the weather and visibility.
ICE REGIME - Photo 1 for Example 1
This photo of a multi-year floe surrounded by broken up medium first year ice was taken in Lancaster Sound in July. The multi year piece is identified by its very smooth surface with no sharp-edged topography. The higher freeboard of multi year ice is also apparent in this scene.
There is little puddling on this floe, and no thaw holes so it would not be considered decayed. One could expect this floe to be two to five metres thick.
This scene contains one tenth multi-year in small floes, and nine tenths medium first year ice as brash.
This will be shown on the ice chart as:
Multi-Year floe in Medium First-year ice
Photo: courtesy Norland Science & Engineering Ltd.
ICE REGIME - Photo 2 for Example 2
Medium Sized Second-Year Floe
Photo: courtesy Norland Science & Engineering Ltd.
This photo of a second-year floe provides a perspective on the size and scale of the topography of a typical second-year floe. Note how the freeboard is lower compared to multi-year ice. The smoother surface and drainage channels are apparent in this photo of second-year ice, similar to multi year ice as well. This flow is estimated at two metres thick.
The concentration in this scene is five tenths second-year in medium floes, four tenths medium first-year in small floes.
This will be shown on the ice chart as:
IMPORTANT ICE REGIME CONCEPTS
- An Ice Regime is any area composed of a relatively even distribution of any mix of ice types, including open water.
- Each ice type has an Ice Multiplier value relevant to the level of difficulty which that ice type may pose for a given ship category.
- Ice Multipliers may be increased for decayed ice and must be decreased for ridging.
- Ice Numerals are calculated based on the concentrations of different ice types within an ice regime, and the corresponding ice multipliers.
- Ice Numerals must be zero or higher for a ship to enter an ice regime.
.3 Determining Ice Regimes
The Ice Navigator may observe the ice conditions visually and determine the types of ice within the ship’s ice regime. In addition, the information about ice conditions may also come from a variety of sources, including:
- The Arctic Vessel Traffic System (NORDREG)
- Ice charts from the “Canadian Ice Service”
- Reports from shore stations and from other ships in the area
- Helicopter reconnaissance
- Direct satellite and airborne radar imagery
The ice charts from the Canadian Ice Service contain information on ice types, concentrations and their distribution which can be used to define Ice Regimes and calculate their severity directly. Other information may require more interpretation by an Ice Navigator.
There is no set maximum or minimum size for an ice regime.
The Ice Navigator must use the best available information to develop a picture of the ice conditions which is relevant to their needs.
The Ice Analysis Charts from Canadian Ice Service, Environment Canada contain information on Ice Types, concentrations and their distribution which are well suited to the Arctic Ice Regime Shipping System. Considering that these charts are presented in an appropriate scale for: voyage planning, strategic planning and to a limited extent tactical navigation, they can be used directly to define ice regimes and calculate their severity. Other forms of information, including digital data may require more interpretation by an experienced Ice Navigator.
A safe regime may consist of a relatively narrow lead through dangerous ice, provided that conditions are likely to remain stable during the transit. The Ice Navigator must not define regimes more locally than is warranted by the ice conditions and the manoeuvring characteristics of the vessel. If inbound, the Ice Navigator must also carefully consider how conditions may change before the outbound journey. The mariner's judgement is crucial throughout. Before entering a regime, there must always be a route to a safe haven or out of the ice.
.4 Planning Routes
In general, routes should be planned to avoid ice as much as possible. Current information on ice should be used to select the easiest routes. If one or more Ice Numerals along an intended route are negative, the mariner should consider an alternate route.
An experienced Ice Navigator may recognize that some broadly drawn regimes with negative numbers are likely to include more local areas through which transits can be made safely. However a factor to consider is that conditions may change. When conditions are deteriorating more caution is needed before entering regimes which may be marginally within the vessel's capabilities.
Routing guidance from NORDREG, taking these and other factors into account, can be of assistance. When reporting voyage plans to NORDREG, the rationale is to be provided for the decisions on selecting routes, particularly if a selected route appears likely to encounter negative Ice Numerals.
.5 Considering Escort
Escort by another ship is another factor which may be considered in planning routes and defining local ice regimes. Under some circumstances an escort can be effective in easing the ice conditions along the route, e.g. breaking large pieces of dangerous ice or assisting vessels to manoeuvre around them. However, there are some situations when the effectiveness of the escorting vessel could be limited e.g. the track becomes narrow indicating that the ice is under pressure.
The Master of the vessel under escort must work closely with the Master of the escorting vessel. The escorting vessel will decide whether it is safe to break a track, but the Master of the escorted ship must continue to evaluate the conditions in order to determine whether it is safe to follow, and at what speed. Good communication between vessels is essential throughout the escorted transit.
The publication Ice Navigation In Canadian Waters (Reference 3), is an excellent source of important information on escort operations.
.6 Training and Experience
Vessels planning to use the Ice Regime system must have on board a Ice Navigator with the required training and experience. It is recognized that the Arctic is a complex environment. For a ship’s performance to remain within safe limits, the Master and the navigating officers should also have the necessary training and experience in ice navigation.
The safety of the ship is the responsibility of Master at all times. This includes avoiding areas with ice regimes beyond the ship's capabilities, and operating at suitable speeds to avoid unsafe collisions with ice. Operating within the Ice Regime System provides a useful framework for operational decisions.
.1 Ice Regime Routing Message
When the Arctic Ice Regime Shipping System is used, the Arctic Shipping Pollution Prevention Regulations require that an Ice Regime Routing Message be sent to the NORDREG. This message can, in general, be very brief, however, if the vessel’s route includes areas on ice analysis charts from the Canadian Ice Service with ice concentrations that may have negative Ice Numerals, the message should include additional pertinent information explaining the voyage plan e.g. expectations of changes in conditions and/or other considerations.
The content of the Ice Regime Routing Message is as follows:
To: Regional Ice Operations Superintendent
NORDREG Canada..................Facsimile: (867) 979-4236
ICE REGIME ROUTING MESSAGE
- the ship’s name,
- the ship’s call sign and IMO number
- the ice strengthening of the ship (Type / CAC / Arctic Class / etc.),
- the date and UTC time,
- the ship’s current position, course and speed,
- the anticipated destination,
- the intended route,
- a listing of the ice regimes and their associated Ice Numerals,
- the source(s) of ice information,
- any other pertinent information / comments
- the name of any escorting vessel, and
- the name(s) of the Ice Navigator(s) on board
This message should be updated if the plan and/or ice conditions change significantly. In any event, the ship should provide an update on entering any area for which it has previously reported a negative Ice Numeral.
.2 After Action Report
When the Arctic Ice Regime Shipping System is used, in accordance with subsection 6(3) of the Arctic Shipping Pollution Prevention Regulations, an after action report is required to be submitted within 30 days of leaving the area. The report can be quite brief, however, in cases where the voyage has involved difficulties or unexpected occurrences, it will be valuable to include the information which the Master considers significant. This information could be useful for the future development of the system and for the overall safety of navigation in the Arctic.
Unlike the routing message, the After Action Report is to be sent to the Regional Director, Marine, Prairie & Northern Region, who receives it on behalf of the Minister of Transport. The content of the After Action Report is as follows:
To: Regional Director, Marine
Prairie & Northern Region - AMNS
Place de Ville, Tower C
330 Sparks Street, 14th Floor
Ottawa, Ontario, K1A 0N5
Telephone: (613) 991-6004
Facsimile: (613) 991-4818
AFTER ACTION REPORT
- the ship’s name,
- the ice strengthening of the ship (Type / CAC / Arctic Class / etc.),
- a description of the actual route, including the: ice regimes encountered, transit speeds and the Ice Numerals for each,
- copies of the ice information used,
escort information, if applicable
- duration of the escort,
- the ice regime under escort, and,
- the characteristics of the track,
- weather conditions and visibility, and
- any other important information.
As has been the case since 1972 with the Zone Date entry system, Marine Safety and the CCG will continue to monitor ship navigation. This is performed at three levels:
- Arctic Canada Traffic System (NORDREG)
- Regional Ice Operations Superintendent
- Marine Safety
The Canadian Ice Service supplies the ice charts that are relayed through the Coast Guard radio stations and NORDREG. They can also provide additional information on request.
.1 Arctic Canada Traffic System
For ships operating in Arctic waters, the Canadian Coast Guard administers and operates the Arctic Canada Traffic System known as NORDREG CANADA. The primary objectives of NORDREG are to:
- enhance the safe and expeditious movement of maritime transportation in Arctic waters;
- safeguard the Arctic environment; and
- contribute to the administration of Canadian Arctic waters and territories
Among its other activities, NORDREG issues acknowledgements to ships entering Arctic waters, distributes ice information and ice routings for individual ships, and co-ordinates requests for Canadian Coast Guard icebreaker assistance. In these areas NORDREG operates in a similar manner to the Eastern Canada Traffic System (ECAREG CANADA), and has similar general reporting requirements. They are contained in the Annual Edition of Notices to Mariners (reference 4).
NORDREG is a voluntary reporting system. All vessels are strongly encouraged to participate. In providing its services, the CCG have made it clear that there is no intention on its part to attempt to navigate or manoeuvre ships from a shore station, or to override the Master’s authority and responsibility for the safe navigation of the ship.
ARCTIC CANADA TRAFFIC SYSTEM
NORDREG CANADA - HIGHLIGHTS
- Compliance with NORDREG CANADA is voluntary.
- Ships reporting to Ice Operations Office, in accordance with NORDREG CANADA, are monitored, and also are better placed to receive expedient support when they request.
- Ice routings issued by NORDREG CANADA are advisory in nature. NORDREG CANADA will not attempt to navigate or manoeuvre ships from a shore station, to over-ride the authorities of Masters, or to take over their responsibilities for the safe navigation of their ships.
.2 Regional Ice Operations Superintendent
The Regional Ice Operations Superintendent will not become involved in operational decision making as a result of the introduction of the Arctic Ice Regime Shipping System. The ship's Master will make the operational decisions according to the system and communicate these decisions to the Ice Operations Superintendent.
These communications do not constitute requests for permission to proceed, rather they are made for the information of the Ice Operations Superintendent. On the basis of this information and other requirements of the NORDREG CANADA system, a NORDREG acknowledgement may be issued for the vessel to proceed along the projected route and through the anticipated ice conditions. This represents an acknowledgement that the planned route appears appropriate - it does not relieve Masters of their responsibility to navigate with due caution and with continuous careful attention to the local ice conditions.
.3 Marine Safety
Marine Safety is the national authority for ensuring safe ships and protecting life, property and the marine environment from ship related impacts.
This mandate, authority and responsibilities are derived from a number of acts, the most important of which are the Canada Shipping Act and the Arctic Waters Pollution Prevention Act.
Marine Safety, performs an oversight on the System, conducts Port State Control inspections, and issues safety certification.
.4 Canadian Ice Service
The Canadian Ice Service is part of Environment Canada’s Atmospheric Environment Service (AES). The goal of the Ice Services Program is to ensure that ice information is available as needed and is used effectively by our clients to make sound decisions that will promote safe and efficient maritime operations for the economic benefit of Canadians while environmental integrity is preserved. The Canadian Ice Service, as an integral part of AES, is a centre of expertise for the ice related information for all of Canada.
To achieve this goal, ice conditions across Canada are monitored using the latest satellite technology as well as aerial reconnaissance, ships and shore reports. Numerical ice models assist experienced ice forecasters in predicting ice growth, movement, deformation and decay.
The Canadian Ice Service produces ice hazard bulletins and ice charts describing the general ice distribution and hazard areas to marine operations. For more specific client needs, ice forecasts and analysis can be produced on request in addition to any consultation service that may be needed. When tactical support is required, a radar equipped aircraft manned by Ice Specialists from AES can be dispatched within 4 hours.
The Canadian Coast Guard, through its marine radio stations, broadcasts the ice bulletins and ice charts produced by the Canadian Ice Service according to schedules published in Radio Aids to Marine Navigation. These products, as well as more detailed information, can be received by fax or electronic mail directly from the Ice Centre in Ottawa. The Canadian Ice Service also has World Wide Web page on the internet. For more details or specific information on ice information products and services, please contact the Canadian Ice Service at:
Telephone: (613) 996-1550 / (800) 767 - 2885
Facsimile: (613) 947-9160
Address: Canadian Ice Service
Block “E”, 3rd Floor
373 Sussex Drive
- ASPPR Sub-Committee On Training And Certification, March 30/31, 1993 Meeting and Recommendations.
- Validation Trials of the Proposed Ice Regime Shipping Control System, “M/T HUBERT GAUCHER” 1992 and “M/V FEDERAL POLARIS”, 1992. (Reports prepared for Canadian Coast Guard.) Norland Science & Engineering Ltd., 1993.
- Ice Navigation In Canadian Waters, 1992 Revised Edition, Canadian Coast Guard.
- Notices to Mariners 1 to 45, Annual Edition, Canadian Coast Guard Marine Navigation Services.
- Proposals For The Revision Of The Arctic Shipping Pollution Prevention Regulations, Volume 1: Background, Volume 2: Regulations, December 1989. (Report of the Sub-Committee for the Canadian Coast Guard) TP 9981
- Vessel Traffic Services, Centre Manual, Arctic Canada Traffic System (NORDREG), Element T-2, June 1994. TP 1526
- WMO Sea-Ice Nomenclature, World Meteorological Organisation 1985 Reference Publication. WMO/OMM/BMO No 259.
- Date modified: