Low Rolling Resistance Tires – Winter Performance

Overview

  1. The Fine Print
  2. Methodology
  3. Part 1 - Laboratory Based Testing
  4. Part 2 - Vehicle Based Testing
  5. Vehicle Testing Results Summary

1. The Fine Print

  • Gross differences in tire performance differences (if any)
    • NOT a tire ranking exercise
  • Tire selection independent of manufacturer support
    • Acquired through channels available to consumers

2. Methodology

  • Lab Based Testing
  • Vehicle Based Testing

3. Part 1 - Laboratory Based Testing

Purpose of Lab Tests

  • Quantify performance differences
  • Help correlate vehicle test results

Limitations

  • Single tire sample per test
  • Snow traction test is an outdoor test
    • Weather dependent
    • Relative
  • Trends & gross differences only
    • No ranking

Test to be Performed

  • Rolling Resistance Measurement 
    • Smithers facility in Ravenna, OH
  • Durability Testing
    • Smithers facility in Ravenna, OH
  • Snow Traction
    • Smithers facility in Raco, MI

Rolling Resistance Results

Figure 1
Text Version of Figure 1

Figure 2
Text Version for Figure 2

Durability Testing

  • Durability testing allows for qualitative comparison. It does NOT model or predict tire lifespan
  • The base test only establishes a minimum level of performance for road worthiness

Durability Testing Results

Figure 3
Text Version for Figure 3

Figure 4
Text Version for Figure 4

Durability Testing Notes

  • At its core, the durability test is only an acceptability test.
  • Durability test does NOT model or predict lifespan.

Snow Traction Testing

  • Based on ASTM F1805, modified for heavy truck tires
  • Results are normalized against a “control” tire
  • Forward (driving) traction only.
    • No lateral component (such as cornering)
    • No braking

Snow Traction Apparatus

An image showing a truck loaded with boxes containing the various data collection apparatuses for the Snow Traction Test

Snow Traction Results

Figure 5
Text Version for Figure 5

Figure 6
Text Version for Figure 6

Lab Results Summary

  • Rolling Resistance
    • SmartWay-verified tires have much lower RR
  • Durability
    • Comparable to non-SmartWay-verified tires
  • Snow Traction
    • Comparable to non-SmartWay-verified tires

4. Part 2 - Vehicle Based Testing

Purpose of Vehicle Based Testing

  • Does a SmartWay-verified designation entail a significantly reduced winter performance?
  • Lab vs. Actual (vehicle based testing)
  • Possible effects on vehicle interaction

Vehicle Setup

  • Extensive instrumentation
    • Vehicle computer
    • GPS
    • IMU
  • Other additional data

Tests to be Performed

  • Stopping Distance Measurement
  • Turning Test
    • On/off ramp analogue

Limitations

  • Single configuration sample per test
  • Weather dependent
  • Trends and gross differences only
    • No ranking

Stopping Distance Results

Figure 7
Text Version for Figure 7

Turning Test

  • Simulation of on/off ramp
  • Road holding ability
  • 180 degree turn, 23 m radius

 

Turning Test Results

  • Pass/Fail only
  Turning Test Entry Speed
Tire
Configuration
20 km/h 25 km/h 30 km/h 35 km/h
A/A PASS PASS PASS FAIL
B/B PASS PASS FAIL not attempted
C/C PASS PASS PASS FAIL
C/D PASS PASS PASS FAIL
E/E PASS PASS PASS FAIL
F/F PASS PASS PASS FAIL

 

Vehicle Testing Results Summary

  • Stopping Distance
    • Comparable to non-SmartWay-verified tires
    • No adverse system interaction
  • Turning/Road Holding
    • Comparable to non-SmartWay-verified tires
    • No adverse system interaction

 

Alternative format

Low Rolling Resistance Tires Winter Performance – Alternative Format - Adobe PDF

To access the Portable Document Format (PDF) version you must have a PDF reader installed. If you do not already have such a reader, there are numerous PDF readers available for free download or for purchase on the Internet:

Please note: The following hyperlinks are to sites of organizations or other entities that are not subject to the Official Languages Act. The material found there is therefore in the language(s) used by the sites in question.

Date modified: